Gainesville Owners Are Switching from Evolve to StayGainesville

Why Gainesville Owners Are Switching from Evolve to StayGainesville

Comparison chart for StayGainesville vs. Evolve

Why Property Owners Are Switching from Evolve to StayGainesville


When you first signed up with Evolve, it probably sounded like a great deal:
✅ Low fees
✅ Professional marketing
✅ Help with bookings


But for many property owners, the reality sets in quickly:


❌ You're still stuck handling cleaners, maintenance, emergencies, and supplies.
❌ You're left coordinating vendors, dealing with scheduling headaches, and fielding guest issues.
❌ You're just another listing among thousands — not a valued partner.


StayGainesville Solves These Problems — and Delivers So Much More


Here’s why more Gainesville property owners are making the switch:


1. Full-Service Management, Not Just Booking Help

Evolve is only a marketing and reservations platform.
StayGainesville is true full-service:

  • Guest communications (24/7)
  • Check-ins and check-outs
  • Professional housekeeping
  • Maintenance coordination
  • Inventory restocking
  • Revenue management
  • Emergency support

With StayGainesville, you don’t just get more bookings — you get full peace of mind.


2. Hands-Off Ownership — No Stress, No Micromanaging

With Evolve, you still have to find cleaners, fix broken items, and handle emergencies.
With StayGainesville,
you never lift a finger.
We manage every single aspect of your short-term rental, so you can finally enjoy truly passive income.


3. Better Guest Experience = Better Reviews = Higher Income

Guests expect fast responses, clean homes, and seamless stays.
StayGainesville delivers
hotel-level service, leading to more 5-star reviews — and higher future earnings for you.

Evolve might help with getting bookings, but without local boots on the ground, guest experiences suffer — and your ratings (and earnings) eventually drop.


4. Local Experts Who Know Gainesville Inside and Out

StayGainesville is based right here in Gainesville — not in a national office somewhere.
We understand:
🏈 The demand spikes during UF game weekends
🎓 The needs of families during UF graduations
🏥 The importance of extended stays for Shands patients and staff

We tailor your pricing, marketing, and property care to Gainesville’s rhythms — not national averages.


5. Real Relationships — Not a Call Center

When you work with StayGainesville, you’re not just another ticket number.
You’ll have
direct communication with a team who knows your property personally — and treats it like their own investment.

With Evolve, you’re typically routed through a national customer service line or email chain, often with little consistency.


6. Higher Overall Returns

Even though StayGainesville’s fee is slightly higher (20% vs Evolve’s ~10%), the value is dramatically better:

  • Higher nightly rates thanks to dynamic, locally-optimized pricing
  • Fewer guest issues and cancellations
  • Higher occupancy rates year-round
  • Lower maintenance costs through preventative care
  • More repeat guests and direct bookings

Most owners net more income with StayGainesville — without the hidden “costs” of self-managing cleaners, emergencies, and turnovers.


Ready for a Better Experience?

✅ Tired of coordinating everything yourself?
✅ Frustrated with inconsistent support?
✅ Want a truly local, expert partner who maximizes your investment?


It’s time to make the switch.

👉 Contact StayGainesville today to see how effortless — and profitable — your property ownership experience can be.

✨ Stay Smart. Stay Local. StayGainesville. ✨

A group of UF Graduates
By Susannah Peddie April 25, 2025
Book Early: StayGainesville Has Properties Available for UF 2025 Graduation! Graduating from the University of Florida is a major milestone, not just for students, but for their families and friends who have supported them throughout their journey. As one of Gainesville’s most exciting and busiest weekends, UF Spring 2025 Graduation will bring thousands of visitors to town — all eager to celebrate, reconnect, and honor years of hard work.
By Susannah Peddie April 25, 2025
StayGainesville vs. Evolve vs. Vacasa: Which is Best for You?
More Posts